Yahoo SMTP Deferrals

As I mentioned before … even though I’m participating in Yahoo’s Email Complaint Feedback Loop, I’m still getting deferrals when trying to deliver mail to Yahoo’s mail servers.   I’ve gotten a few complaints, but not nearly enough to really justify having mail delivery deferred.

I think I’ve figured out a bit more about why Yahoo’s mail servers are deferring some of the mail my servers try to deliver to them.

The error being returned by yahoo’s server’s is:

<> Deferred: 421 4.7.0 [TS02] Messages from
temporarily deferred due to user complaints –; see

I think that the phrase ”user complaint’ is not entirely accurate … I suspect that a ‘user complaint’ can also be generated (although not reported as such) by Yahoo’s anti-spam technology.

So I created a new Yahoo email account for myself and subscribed it to one of my mailing lists.   I then waited for mail to start coming in.

What I found was: Some mail was getting categorized as spam and mail was still getting deferred by Yahoo’s servers.

So, what I’m guessing is … mail tagged as spam by Yahoo’s anti-spam system is being categorized as a ‘user complaint’ … which is causing the deferrals (even though there is no specific user complaint).   Unfortunately, the email headers in Yahoo’s mail system do not give an indication as to why a message was considered spam.   There are some headers in the message that might have some information … but it’s all obfuscated.

My system’s mail traffic is still being evaluated by Yahoo … which will take at least two weeks to complete.   Hopefully they will figure out that the mail my system generates is not spam and stop deferring it’s delivery.

Related posts ...
Well, our good friends at Yahoo are at it again. Once again they are deferring
I put together a new SpamAssassin rule that will help identify spam from spoofed email
It's nice that many of the major mail providers give you the ability to report
While doing a little searching, I found some information on email feedback loops for other

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.